Critique - Mannequin Hands

769
Course In Progress

Critique - Mannequin Hands

769
Course In Progress
Stan Prokopenko
Let’s take a look at your Mannequin Hands! In this critique, I’ll be looking through both level 1 and level 2 submissions and giving feedback on common mistakes.
Newest
@shopdoc
1d
Looking for some advice. And I hope I am explaining this well. I understand the Y trick and having lines converge when going away from the Y. However, when doing exercises such as these hands, I don't always start with the Y when attaching one part of the digit to another. At times I ended up establishing my box and then the Y which required me to erase some lines and converge away from the Y that I established after the fact. Any advice on drawing these converging (or maybe diverging depending on how the box is initially established) when you cannot start with a Y?
Stefan Sharkov
Here are my level 2 sketches. My attempts to draw the hand from another angle were a challenge, but I made sure that even if the position wasn't exact, the boxes were still drawn in perspective correctly. I apologize for the crunkled paper on the last sketch; transportation issues.
Chauncey Holder
After doing them I think I got the hang of them. It's a bit easier to do after revewing the criqtue
Natasha Johnson
I really love this lesson , so after the critique i went back and red penciled my mistakes …. There was too many (mistakes) so post critique i did this hand again and was more mindful of my lines and perspective . This will be a warm up that will always be enjoyed . Thanks Stan
Jack H
4mo
Final set of hands after watching the critique video. I've definitely grown more comfortable drawing boxes in 3D, but they're far from perfect. Coming up with the hands from imagination is still really difficult for me. But oh well, on to the next lesson.
Luke Ng
5mo
Here's another attempt at the level 2 assignment after using some tips from seeing Stan's demo and critique After finishing it I see that I'd made a mistake on the finger proportions segments
@breakfast
8mo
More level 2
@daniellee
8mo
I'm coming to drawing very late in life and I had only just learned of Kim Jung Gi before his tragic passing. I learned of him through Sorie Kim's sketching course on Domestica and then through Stan's interviews. I know he's been gone for almost two years now but it's still very sad to talk about him in the past tense. R.I.P Kim Jun Gi.
William Mclean
i have that problom of being sloppy. just want to get done fast so i dont think
May Berry
10mo
My second attempt at the project using different references. Started using value to differentiate the planes. Drew additional rhythm lines to help me with the rotation of the fingers. It also helped to find the eye level.
Mireina
11mo
When I spotted a chance for critique, I mistakenly interpreted the assignment, drawing everything in a boxy style, but not literally as single boxes... 😅 However, I like this approach as keeping everything clean is just easier. Did a few more studies in this style (I even matched the next lesson with drawing glasses! ) after the deadline, critique or tips are very welcome :D Can't wait for the lesson about twisting and bending!
Patrick Bosworth
Beautiful work. These are excellent studies!!
Scott
11mo
Thanks Stan for the excellent course. I am making progress. I appreciate the way this course is laid out and the patience required by teacher and student alike to build up concepts and techniques slowly. You are also a fun instructor. Keep up the good work!
Brandon
11mo
After the critique, I tried to redraw some of the fingers while giving more thought on drawing boxes instead of hand. 'treating each finger as a box that has its own seperate vanishing points' is what I took away from the last lesson. how the form rotate and its relation with lines convergence n change to a more confident mindset are what I learnt from this lesson. Thx a lot. Now I am kind of brainwashing myself to stay confident and committed to each line I draw btw I think we should have more lessons similar to the last one, so that we can listen when we draw.
Conrado "Croc" Ramos Rezende
I think i can rest in peace now, i got critiqued by Stan "The Proko" Prokopenko! Thanks, not only for my critique. All of them were very helpful. Gonna redo it.
Juice
1yr
Ooh curvy twisty things sound like fun
Dermot
1yr
Stan, thanks for these critiques. It's a fun exercise and challenge. You've covered plenty to consider, I'll watch a few more times and practice more.
Juice
1yr
What you said as an exersice to Martin drawing something else in form of boxes and reimagine the angle. I made that before with a cool picture and pose of the Hulk :) and made it from a different angle. I didnt post it though. It was fun!
Stan Prokopenko
Let's see it!
Dennis Yeary
even though I didn't get a critique. i got a lot out of it
Full course
You will be given unexpiring access to watch the videos online .
View course details
Give a gift
Give a gift card for art students to use on anything in the Proko store.
Or gift this course:
About instructor
Founder of Proko, artist and teacher of drawing, painting, and anatomy. I try to make my lessons fun and ultra packed with information.
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!