Critique - Collecting Masters
Critique - Collecting Masters
This lesson is premium only. Join us in the full course!
57:46

Critique - Collecting Masters

1.6K
Course In Progress

Critique - Collecting Masters

1.6K
Course In Progress
Marshall Vandruff
Let's take a look through some of your favorite drawings by perspective masters and big picture goals.
Newest
Sheri Jensen
My goal is to use perspective in oil paintings. I want to know the rules so I can break them if the subject warrants.
Stevie Roder
This was a really fun video to watch and learn from Marshall. I've been loving your course a ton thus far. I hated missing the deadline for this critique session since it was my fault for forgetting to post, but I still learned much from it. I'm so glad to be a part of this course because of your wisdom and getting back into drawing again thanks to this course. I am honestly learning way more than I ever did when I took my drawing class over at my college, and it is making me want to take time to draw more slowly again, which I can't thank you enough for doing, Marshall. Now that the fall semester is finally coming to its ending course pretty quickly. I shall be finding lots of time from here on out to put in some amazing new work within the fun lessons soon, with more free time I'll be gaining between semesters during my break. This was a great watch on listening to you giving great advice through the critiques, though. I am learning tons, and it is honestly making me glee with joy enough to take another drawing class at my college again to boost my desire to have more fun with it next semester for the extra postage. Thanks, Marshall. One reason I'd love to get good with perspective highly is to truly dig in deep where I would be yet again positive with my drawings to start getting better with my environmental drawings enough I can be confident enough to share with my friends. One of my other goals is to feel accomplished with my drawings since I'm a self-learning gamedev/animator who wants to get good with environment work well enough to incorporate them into my future works.
Sirikirtan Fluck
Hello - I totally enjoy this class and really enjoy the posts so far! Very inspiring and I find myself hungry to learn it all ~ I am a 70 yo woman, and have found my passion in learning to draw, especially architecture (if I had to do it again, I'd surely be an architect). I also want to be able to draw cars (classic/ vintage/ muscle), classic motorcycles, trucks (again vintage/ classic and large, industrial ones, too), planes and boats. I hope to be able to draw in any orientation and to be able to design my own as well. Although I haven't included any examples from Scott Robertson, I'd like to be able to use his tools to design them. As for architecture, I am especially enamored of Neutra, but a lot of MCM and Victorian examples are high on my list. I am also late to post, but I hope that some of these type of ideas/ examples can be useful in our study.
Shelly Ryder
Sad that I missed the beginning of this course. Feel like I am chasing a bit! But here are some of my favourites! As a mathematician, I have always enjoyed using geometry in my artworks. Inspired by artists such as Leonardo da Vinci, Pieter Bruegel the Elder, Vincent Van Gogh, James Turrell and Julie Mehretu. Just a one example of each below. Probably not as traditionally 'perspective' as some of the others shown below. L. da Vinci - The Last Supper for me shows a great sense of depth with converging lines to pull the focus into the centre where Jesus is sat. It makes the room feel huge and enhances the impact. Pieter Bruegel the Elder - Landscape with the Fall of Icarus captures my imagination with the inclusion of mythological elements but also because of the use of atmospheric perspective. The fading colours and softening of detail in the distance are very clever. Vincent van Gogh - Bedroom in Arles so incredibly clever. A photographic technique applied well before it was invented with the skewed perspective it makes you feel like you are in a tiny little room. It feels very intimate. James Turrell - Aten Reign. This guy ... just wow! If you haven't heard of him, you should have a look. He manipulates light and space and creates immersive environments. Really cool. Julie Mehretu - Stadia II uses complex perspective merging different views and spaces that feels quite chaotic. A true exploration of perspective. I am a painter (as you can probably tell from my selections) and use Vedic shapes to create abstract landscapes. This course will be perfect for learning to create some space and depth in my paintings. Very excited for the year!
@chadhands
25d
Some of these pictures, the more last once are some of the stuff I learned already but I had to stop my learning after drawing that car. I am looking to get back it and learn much much more. I'm hope I can get assistance if I have any questions as I am learning in this course.
Shayan Shahbazi
Thank you so much for teaching me how to break down my goals, I really appreciate that. By the way you pronounce my name correctly, professor.
@bert2
29d
What a great project i loved discovering new artist. Here is a drawing with an interesting perspective i like. title : Cyril Power - The Tube Train (1934)
Marshall Vandruff
A great example! So properly "bent" for effect! Thanks for posting.
Deborah Donofrio
Many people in this course are interested in manga and anime. Hope there are a few artists of the classical genre. My goal is to be so good at perspective that people will say, Wow, that’s a beautiful painting! and only Marshall will immediately see it’s because the perspective is spot on. Lol.
Marshall Vandruff
Well, not ONLY Marshall. I'm getting the feeling that these Manga and Anime lovers will not only see Perspective keenly, they may evolve their genres yet further. You, Deborah, are collecting treasures of the past, arranging them for beauty and impressiveness, and giving us views through long and short lenses. Lovely collection.
Randy Pontillo
I'm fighting the urge not to confuse myself by looking into orthos early, I've never heard of it before!
Marshall Vandruff
Nothing wrong with looking ahead if you're interested. But believe me, we will get into them...
Li Ming Lin
Wow, these drawings are terrific inspirations! Completely blown away!
Johannes Schiehsl
The collection of images brought together by the community is amazing and also overwhelming. I agree with Marshall when he suggests that we sort our idols into sub folders for different stages of our learning. I have been working on a set of categories to sort my "art heroes" for a while now, because there are so many. I try to analyse what exactly I admire about their work and what I want to learn from them. I made a little chart of the system that I curently use - if you have ideas and suggestions I am looking forward to them. Happy sorting!
Marshall Vandruff
Good thinking Johannes!
Andreas Kra
This is a great chart for the categories! I love the little illustrations and the additional explanations. The only thing that comes to mind is that it could include the genre or medium the artist is using (e.g., storyboard, illustration, painting, comic, tattoo, etc.). But maybe that's a subcategory of the subject + story? I’m not sure. Great notes—thanks for sharing!
@sarbearstare
I am so friggin psyched for this class.
Andreas Kra
Here are my notes so far. There are some neat tricks and tips in the review—thanks, Marshall! When studying perspective in a masterpiece, thinking about a slider with two extremes helps to better understand the bigger picture: - instructional (how-to) vs. showcasing for maximum impact - simplified vs. detailed - close vs. far away - huge vs. tiny - inside vs. outside - looking down vs. looking up (into the scene) - organic vs. rigid/mechanical - wide-angle vs. compressed 2D shapes layered on top of each other - strict mathematical rules vs. purposely bending principles for storytelling
Marshall Vandruff
Nothing is wasted on you! So pleased to see you taking these spectra seriously. I hope that someday, in the throes of your creative output, your ability to combine, balance, contrast, juxtapose, crescendo, slide, and play among any of those opposites will empower your work in surprising new ways. Thank you Andreas!
Johannes Schiehsl
Good stuff! I love those sliders! I wanna click them and slide along - would be a fun tool.
Carlye Luft
Master the basics. Got it!
@ivandot
1mo
hi, is there any way to see the pictures like marshalls see its in the critique? like a gallery in scroll down?
Max Long
1mo
The pictures are on the assignments for the first video of the course. That video is titled “Perspective for drawing anything”. There are over 300 posts that people sent pictures to be critiqued.
Dermot
1mo
Marshall, thanks for sharing everyones critiques. I found it very difficult choosing a selection of pictures for the first assignment as I'm so near the vanishing point amoung the amazing artists that posted their interesting choices of artwork. It's all an education to me. Thanks Again.
Andreas Kra
I was drawing along while watching the critique video. Sometimes studying feels like eating disliked vegetables or taking medicine—it’s good for you but uncomfortable. But in this perspective course, I feel like I want more, and Marshall keeps us on the edge of our seats, waiting for the next lesson to digest. I’m excited for the next videos. Let’s start creating and learning!
Marshall Vandruff
You are indeed both learning and creating!
@lieseldraws
Amazing stuff!
Angelica Golindano
I’m confused as to how to or where to post “assignments” — where did people place these images used for the latest critique in the perspective course.
Dermot
1mo
Hi Angelica Golindano I think this link to the first lesson is the assignment picture post refered too. https://www.proko.com/course-lesson/perspective-for-drawing-anything/assignments :)
@wonderphantom
Usually the comment section of a lesson video serves as the place to post your assignements. In this case you were supposed to post your chosen images in the comment section of lesson 1 "Perspective for Drawing Anything".
Ramzi Chamcham
Same, couldn't find these images!
@jaejaelearning
Every video so far I walk away feeling like I've learned something, and it perplexes me because I am not always aware that the learning is happening until after the video ends. Marshall, your method of teaching delights the mind, and instead of feeling crushed and exhausted as I often am by what I can only describe as traditional teaching methods- I am always left full of more questions, curiosity, and intrigue. I haven't felt this way about learning in a long time. Loved this video! It's really left me thinking and pondering about my initial selection of art treasures, and prompting me to look at art with a new mindset of not just trying to identify any perspective but perspective that is useful to learn from. Upon reflection, I think my fear of backgrounds did lead me to initially pick examples of perspective applied to characters mostly, but I am feeling less daunted already and loving looking at the examples other have chosen. I was most fascinated this lesson by the notion of things 'flattening' as they get further away. I would have assumed they would become more warped, not less. But I can't not see it now.
Marshall Vandruff
Your first sentence is one of the most satisfying compliments you could give a teacher. Sometimes an exciting enlightenment, like a mountaintop experience, disappears when we come down from the mountain. Other times, a less dramatic experience yields week-after-year of insight. Thank you jaejaelearning. And may even the things that you now "can't not see" have their own surprising twists later as you keep learning and growing.
Ethyn
1mo
I love the idea of splitting the works into sub-categories to study specific things from; I feel like this could be useful for any project!
Randy Pontillo
Me too! I was getting the feeling that my choices were very composition focused! Having that validated, being offered a solution, and being taught how to find good references instead is awesome!
@jaejaelearning
Yes! You're not alone in this. I found it particularly eye opening as well.
Use Code BLACK20 to Save 20%
Course in Parts
View course details
Give a gift
Give a gift card for art students to use on anything in the Proko store.
Or gift this course:
About instructor
I Write, I Draw, I Teach
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!