Critique - Simplify to CSI

8.1K
Course In Progress

Critique - Simplify to CSI

8.1K
Course In Progress
Stan Prokopenko
Let's take a look at your "Simplify to CSI" submissions! I decided to combine both level 1 & 2 students for this critique since I saw very similar mistakes at both levels.
Newest
@superokay
ā€¢
4d
Attempting a bird using these techniques. I want to improve my line confidence, I guess repetition is the only way to improve that. Luckily Iā€™m really enjoying simplifying these images
Melanie Scearce
Great!
C3
ā€¢
19d
C3
ā€¢
21d
@canuckgirl1
ā€¢
21d
I redid the snail and boots. Got stumped on the shoelaces. Critique more than welcome
Melanie Scearce
It looks like you were on to something with the shoe laces in your first attempt. It may be a matter of getting worn out by the time you get to the shoelaces -- if that's the case, maybe try taking a break before you start so you can begin with fresh eyes. It may help you to try very lightly drawing an "envelope" that encompasses the overall shape of the object. These will be a few light lines meant to help you control the size of the overall drawing so you don't worry about running out of room or changing proportions to make sure the drawing doesn't run off the page. It doesn't have to be exact, just enough get the general proportions accurate. Hope that helps!
@blackhand
ā€¢
27d
The self study point is well taken. I actually traced the boots once, before I drew them, to try to get the feel for laying down the lines without obsessing about the accuracy.
@skylarsmithe
ā€¢
29d
Did the shoes multiple times. Lines definitely looking better than the snail one.
Tony Zhang
ā€¢
1mo
Drawing feet literally sucks.
C3
ā€¢
22d
Good lines
@20thunderbird17
Here is the second attempt after watching the video. Please, any feedback is wanted!
pinkfin
ā€¢
1mo
Spent a lot of time on this project, was challenging for me. Partly it took a long time because i was scared to start drawing shoelaces... I redrew boots couple of times because was not proud of my line art but at the end my hand got used to putting the lines down and honestly i like the result even though i think i didn't do so great with shoelaces. Would really appreciate some criticism!
C3
ā€¢
21d
Good attempt
Rachel Dawn Owens
You did great! These are super clean drawings. Itā€™s ok to be a little sketchy. Donā€™t worry about the details too much. As long as it reads, youā€™re ok.
@vitor_tumoli
ā€¢
2mo
First version of the snail task. Happy to receive feedback
@zaneki
ā€¢
2mo
tried the boots again after watching some crits, found myself getting very frustrated and unable to focus so i rushed a bit. critique appreciated
Melanie Scearce
If you find yourself getting overwhelmed or frustrated, I think it's a good practice to put it down for a bit and take a break. It's like hitting the reset button. When you come back to it refreshed you may notice something that you didn't before. For having rushed I think this looks great! Would like to see those laces finished. Good luck :)
Tommy Pinedo
ā€¢
2mo
I attemped the snail, boots, and camel before doing the skull as I left that as the last one. This was my first attempt. I like it, I am not sure if I should redo it. Any feedback?
Tommy Pinedo
ā€¢
2mo
I decided I am going to redo it. I can improve on line quality. lol
Dominic Statuto
Attempt one of the snail and boot project, as well as my second attempt on the boots. I feel that my boots improved proportion wise, although my line control for the laces is still pretty terrible.
@jackb
ā€¢
2mo
I attempted lvl 1 and lvl 2 and then loosely repeated whilst following along with the demo (I donā€™t copy exactly but just try to get a feel for what stan is saying as he goes along) I went a bit too into the details for this but overall am quite happy with these
Tommy Pinedo
ā€¢
2mo
I like all of them. Yes I agree on the first attempts there are more details, I did that too and for this exercise we are supposed to simplify it which I see the improvement in simplification on the second attempts! Very well done! :)
@zaneki
ā€¢
2mo
watched the first 5 min of this vid and immediately knew i screwed up on the assignment lol (wasn't simplifying enough). tried again with a figure. any critique for my use of CSI?
Maria Gaitan
ā€¢
2mo
CSI Practice
Melanie Scearce
Beautiful work!
Astral Castle
ā€¢
2mo
I did the boots & snail first, then watched the demo on them, and realized that I was kind of doing the project wrong. So i tried simplifying the last two a bit more.
Tommy Pinedo
ā€¢
2mo
As the level increases, I notice the improvement in line quality. The snail and the boots were a bit too scratchy, but in level 2, the lines are more crisp and confident. Thats progress! nice!!!! :)
devin
ā€¢
2mo
I am a super noob at drawing. I was happy to see an improvement in my looser lines by the 3rd snail. The boots overwhelmed me, I want to practice basic lines and try the boots again.
Tommy Pinedo
ā€¢
2mo
I can see that you are improving. I can see the overwhelming energy on the first attempts, especially on the boots. However, you are getting the idea on the second attempt. What helped me on the boots when I felt that the laces overwhelmed was watching stan attempt and critique. for the boots I: 1. Mapped it out using big shapes using lines and angles. I focus on that as long as it takes me. 2. I then use the CSI lines to draw out the boots. I ghost it first maybe 3 to 5 times so my hand can know what to do. If there is an area where I am like damn even ghosting it feels like it might not come out right, I lightly draw the line to "test" if it looks good. If i put so much pressure on it and it looks bad, the line can be hard to erased. I hope this helps, but overall I see improvement. Take your time, there is no rush, no race, just enjjooyyyy the process :)
Andrea Sambrano
Simplified camel number 2. No details, no shading, I tried to use sweeping strokes.
Rachel Dawn Owens
I really like this camel šŸŖ
WilIiam tanuji
ā€¢
3mo
Here are my attampts. I did not add any shading, tried to emphasize on line confidence, and simplified the reference. Feel free to leave feedback or critiques. Thank you.
WilIiam tanuji
ā€¢
3mo
Thank you Rachel for the feedback. that is my fourth attempt drawing the camel. I will continue practicing.
Rachel Dawn Owens
Looks like you got it! I like your camel šŸŖ
Full course
You will be given unexpiring access to watch the videos online .
View course details
Give a gift
Give a gift card for art students to use on anything in the Proko store.
Or gift this course:
About instructor
Founder of Proko, artist and teacher of drawing, painting, and anatomy. I try to make my lessons fun and ultra packed with information.
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and weā€™ll get back to you as soon as possible!