here is my submission, waiting for next exercise

This seemed hard in the beginning, as I started doing it became clearer and interesting.

Was hard but managed to make some rocks. Was able to add some cracks too, tried them digitally. Was fun doing digitally

Great exercise. Will have to do lot more of these to get my head around how the horizon line changes perspective. Here are my three submission last of them is done digitally.

Another interesting assignment, learning so much doing these assignments. Here are my level 1 and 2 assignments

I understand the blob approach a little. It does make drawing little easier. Just imagining the blob moving in different direction without actual construction lines that needs to be precise is definitely simpler. I am a beginner so took a very simple object, but looking at other students beautiful work is giving me motivation to try harder. Will try to post more.

A great video. Watching all the great sketching videos of 12 days of Christmas series had me discouraged a bit, but watching yours renewed my hope if I keep practicing consistently, and lean on talented people for help when I need it, I will be able to achieve my best. Thank you

Thank you Stan for critique. I am so happy you choose mine. While doing the assignment I was confused. You have cleared my doubts. In the video you had mentioned about the fruit that looked like kiwi, well that is a fruit found in Cambodia called Logan.

Well I am late for submitting the assignment but here is my submission. I was able to do make lines intersect in the center but they are wobbly. Also the points on the circle are not exactly where they should be

What an interesting assignment. This assignment has taught me to look at a painting not just with admiration but with attitude to analyze , understand, and get inspired by a painting. Here is my submission. Three of the studied paintings First---Thomas Moran I could find 4 elements in this landscape of cliffs of Green River Wyoming by Thomas Moran. D -Diminution -biggest cliff looks closest and the further away cliffs are smaller in size. Even the figures are getting smaller as they are moving further away. Size of trees is bigger in front than at the back. C- Convergence -Cliffs are converging towards left same is with group of people, animals and trees. F- Foreshortening- I could not find evidence of that here. O Overlap- lots of evidence. First the Cliffs main subject of the landscape has cliffs overlapping. Figures and trees are also overlapping. A -Atmosphere. Clouds in sky and their shadows on cliffs and bit of fog on cliffs is a way that Mr. Moran has depicted the depth in this beautiful landscape Second---Andre Bouvard Andre Bouvard’s –Venice In this landscape D--I see use of Diminution when artist made the right side building bigger and left side houses are much smaller giving illusion, we as an observer are closer to right building. Again the green door on right looks much bigger to the brown door on the big building giving impression that smaller building with tree is the closest. C -Convergence one point convergence is very clear F –Foreshortening. Here too I could not find any evidence of it. It might be I do not understand Foreshortening. O –Overlap-Various buildings overlapping, pink sailboat overlapping yellow sailboat making it recede. Gondolas are overlapping. A Atmosphere -Hazy sky and blurred building at the back. Third --Jim Lee Trinity by Jim Lee D -Diminution Look at the buildings, building in foreground are bigger than ones in background. As the building are receding artist made them smaller. C -Convergence - Artist made three figures which are converging. White rays in sky seem to be converging to same point. F -Foreshortening – There is plenty of evidence. Superman figure, exaggerated fist, thigh of batman, legs of wonder woman. O -Overlap- Overlapping buildings, plane overlapping buildings and three figures overlapping everything. A -Atmosphere – Blurred buildings in background and clouds in sky