Playing with Head Shapes – Thumbnail Sketch Critique
This lesson has a premium version with extra content. Get it now!

Playing with Head Shapes – Thumbnail Sketch Critique

201K
Mark as Completed

Playing with Head Shapes – Thumbnail Sketch Critique

201K
Mark as Completed
Newest
Carlos Javier Roo Soto
Here's my Harold Finch Thumbnails Sketches after watching this critique and some feedback I got from Mods and a coworker, plus new Thumbnails of this McKinnon lady. And some more of my live sketches from work where I tried to keep in mind my feedback.
Kendall Hart
My attempt at Bill Murray…just can’t find that likeness.
Martha Muniz
Hi Kendall! Good sketches--in caricature it always helps to try different approaches as you test what works and what gets you closer to the likeness. I see you're playing around with his droopy eyes and wide nose and I like how you focused first on just his facial features, as the "T" zone (eyes + nose) can really make or break likeness. I think it would help to try out different approaches to the face shape alone, as this can dictate the weight distribution thus where the features will land and gravitate towards once placed all together. I gave this one a try and wrote down some notes about what stood out to me, and while the fun thing about caricature is how differently everyone can interpret a face, I hope it can be useful to you :)
Kendall Hart
I think this one is a tad closer
@adopebee
3yr
This is my next try of thumbnailing. This time I took Mike Akerfeldt. I really tried to take care of time and just focused on what I had in mind. Maybe the sketches doesn't look good but they contain the things I wanted to try. The final sketch (the big one) is something I wanttake to Abstraction. Any feedback is appreciated.
Account deleted
Hi Adopedee, I think you've captured the essence of your subject here. My only note might be the size of the mouth. You've sketch it quite small. But to me the subject's mouth looks wider than normal in the reference photos. Maybe you'll want to play with that feature a bit? Just a thought. Cheers!
@adopebee
3yr
After valuable feedback, I tried again with singer Dani Filth. My goal was sketching fast but still keep the important information readable. Important for me was that the basic head shape becomes visible and the distribution and proportion of the facials can be recognized. After trying different head shapes I stick to the squared shape and tried to make it more recognizable. All together I spend about 25 minutes on this exercise now. I looks pretty messy but I want to work it out later and for me it is understandable.
Germán Olivera
Hi there, great use of shapes, I decided to give it a go aswell :) If I can give a suggestion, you shouldn't ignore the room that the face ocuppies in the head. It looks like you are filling the headshape with the face whereas Dani´s face looks rather small in comparison to his head size. Think about it like the blank space in a composition, it gives room to breath.
@adopebee
3yr
Next try. I am getting better in keeping the head shape.
João Bogo
3yr
Hey, adopebee Nice work. Took a look at all the work you posted and I can see that you're getting more likeness with each caricature and your style is evolving too. Congratulations on that. However, I noticed also that you're doing, in most cases just 1 caricature per person, and you're also taking a lot of time to do it, which kinda defeats the purpose of this exercise, in specific. If you want to study the likeness, that's ok. If you want to test your rough sketch skills, awesome. But to really exercise your designs skills, your creative decisions and your face analyzing abilities these short, experimental 2-3 minutes caricatures are the best. It's in this part of the process your main goal is throw every idea on the wall and see what stick. Test and experiment every possibility you can think of in a couple of minutes without getting attached and evaluate which one can lead to an interesting caricature that you can invest more time. Always taking too much time in the first sketch can stifle your creativity in the long run and make you use the the same exaggeration over and over again. So, take your time to experiment. Best Regards
@adopebee
3yr
I felt more comfortable this time. It was pretty fast sketch not thinking too much about it. I appreciate any feedback.
Jesper Axelsson
Hi @adopebee, nice sketch! I took the class a year ago, so I'm still relatively new to caricature, but I gave making 3(+) min thumbnail sketches of these two images a shot, to see if I would exaggerate anything differently. In the first image her large round forehead was the first thing that caught my attention. I also noticed that her eyes were large, and widely spaced. Her eyebrows, ears, nose, lips and chin appeard small to me. Her jaw seemed strong, yet round. Her neck thin and shoulders bony. I also found the shape of her lips to be very characteristic. Her hair was also very wild and expressive In the second image, the brows felt wider and the forehead less dominant. The face felt longer, especially the mouth area, and I chose to shorten the nose. Her bone structure and mouth musculature, also looked very prominent in the contour. The thumbnail sketch is meant to be a kinda wild process were you follow your gut and jump right into things, but one thing that has helped me is to think of the bigger shapes before committing to details; thinking more about shape relationships, than structure and anatomy. Hope this helps :)
@adopebee
3yr
I am still getting stuck in the same headshape. Maybe I should create a template with different headshapes to experiment on.
@stellaevesenior
Hello Court, I am enjoying the assignment.. but struggling to generate a wide variety of head shapes.. once I've found one that seems ok I kinda get stuck with it. Found that using different drawing tools really helped.. and nearly always spent too long on each sketch. But... it was fun!!! :) Ps. apologies for poor image quality but no scanner at this end. PPs. and couldn't find all the original images I worked from for Dan & Ben.
@stellaevesenior
Thank you for your thoughts Jcarter... so I gave it a quick go! circle, triangle, square..etc Definitely a useful exercise for loosening up head shape.. and indicates more possibilities to push the features also.. Could you post a sample of your own work with this strategy?
@stellaevesenior
I also wanted to ask a another question. Having done quite a lot of traditional portraiture/life drawing I always find myself drifting back toward classical (representational) proportions... any more tips on managing this tendency... or simply a question of time and exposure to exaggeration?? Thanks
@adopebee
3yr
I started my first "subject". This is my best thumbnail so far. I cleaned it up so that it is more recognizable. But it takes me still very long to finish a thumbnail.
Sue Ahn
3yr
Hi this is assignment for thumbnail sketch lesson. Last one is snoop dogg and rest of other photos are the same person even though they are all different
Court Jones
I love the head shapes you came up with. Great variety! And that is the biggest takeaway I want people to get from this lesson. At this stage, simply explore the widest variety of shapes that you can. Even if most of them are unsuccessful, that's okay. The point is not to get ten great sketches. It's to get just one decent sketch with some potential. And then use that one to develop into a rough sketch at the next phase.
João Bogo
3yr
These are very good. i like how you're altering the proportions to fit the character. Even if is the same person you're varying the designs to better represent it. Very good! You're also getting more and more likeness as you sketch more. Keep experimenting with shapes. The Snoopy Dogg ones are the ones that show less likeness, but I feel they were the more productive of your studies because you really explored his face. You varied head shapes, sharpness of the face, proportions, angles... and as you're doing that you're discovering new possibilities and learning what works and what doesn't. Nice work, keep drawing and best regards.
Thieum
3yr
Hello everyone, I'm happy to do my first post in this great and exciting new community! This is my first try of thumbnail sketches of the charismatic Tommy Lee Jones. I'm not shure if there is one with enought likeness to go furher with a rough sketch. I will have to look for more likeness I guess. Happy drawings to everyone!
Court Jones
Wow, really nice thumbnail sketches. They're all really different from each other. I would say that four of them could definitely be developed into nice caricature likenesses. The one on the upper left corner is probably the least successful. But the other four are very inspiring.
sara keyes
3yr
I want to have my thumb sketch critique but I don't know how to post it. I don't have a smart phone and Facebook either. I practice them with Hillary photos. I'll practice them continue.
Sue Ahn
3yr
Hi Sara, under the write reply box, on your right far side, you will see the small mountain picture icon. if you click on it, you will see the mouse cursor changes into hand shape. click on it and click browse file and click what you done. for a smart phone.
Use Code BLACK20 to Save 20%
Course in Parts
View course details
Give a gift
Give a gift card for art students to use on anything in the Proko store.
Or gift this course:
About instructor
Freelance commercial illustrator and caricature entertainer. He’s done a lot of editorial and product illustration and concept work for film and TV.
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!