Activity Feed
Alberto Grubessi
Hi guys, it's been a while since i posted here. I'm doing these illustrations for a portfolio for illustration in novels and i would like some critique on it. Please tell me in your opinion what could be better. The novel is "The masque of Red Death" by Edgar Allan Poe. P.S. some illustrations have a box on the side but this will be removed in the finalized version
@paper
Hello I made this cover,based on the Natsuo Kirino's book,real world.Would love some critism of what's not working(also would like to know if the font's too small)
Alberto Grubessi
I think the composition works but the font is really too small
Jon Neimeister
These are looking great overall and are great fundamental practice! It's awesome seeing you limit your values so the subjects clearly stand out as light shapes against the dark background, that goes a long way towards clarity in finished pieces. Two small suggestions: 1) Some of your form edges are a bit too hard. Remember shadows happen as planes turn away from the light, so a form with sharp plane changes (like a cube) will have hard edged shadows, but a form where the planes gradually turn away from the light source (like a sphere) will have softer edged shadows. You're doing this on some of these, but there's a lot of spheres and softer forms in these with hard-edged core shadows that should be soft. 2) Watch out for your reflected lights becoming too bright. In most of these the reflected light is getting close to the value of the midtones, which starts to break apart the shadow shape and hurt the illusion of form. There are situations where this can happen, but in most cases it's best to be sure that *all* the values on the shadow side are darker than any of the values on the light side. Overall fantastic studies, keep up the good work! :D
Alberto Grubessi
thank you so much, i will keep your advice in mind while i continue doing studies
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!