On Courses + Tools use code BLACK20
@andreyostr
@andreyostr
Earth
Activity Feed
Izak van Langevelde
The rule mentioned by Robertson and others is a rule of thumb. It is not mathematically correct. However, it is the only practical guideline known to mankind, so let's stick to it...
@andreyostr
This rule has a very easy explanation. Even if the information following your link is correct and true, the human eye is capable to see in focus only limited portion of the whole picture. So in order to draw a cylinder, one would look at it in a way, that the object (in our case ellipse) is in the middle of our sight. And in that case the rule with minor axis is 100% valid. To draw an ellipse on the other side of the cylinder one would again move eyes to see it clearly. And the rule will work again. So in fact people, when they create a picture, they fake the perspective. And only if you follow strictly mathematical approach you would get that confusing situation. And that also happens if you create mathematically correct drawing with a very wide angle of view (bigger that 30 degrees), which human eye is not even capable to catch. I hope that explanation was clear enough.
@andreyostr
Actually that rule is valid (also very approximately) in very few cases. In most of the cases center of the ellipse will be located somewhere else: sometime on one of the diagonals, sometimes on the middle line of the square.
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!